Thursday 1 January 2015

Girl arrested over chalk flowers





  • Girl, 14, arrested and put into children's home for drawing flowers on wall at former protest site

  • Court considering application from police that she be removed from father's care

  • Girl's lawyer said move was "premature and disproportionate"




Hong Kong (CNN) -- A 14-year-old girl in Hong Kong could be removed from her father's care after she was arrested for drawing chalk flowers on a wall at one of the city's pro-democracy protest sites.


The girl was arrested in the early hours of December 23 at a staircase leading to the Central Government Offices in the city's Admiralty district and was detained by police for 17 hours, said Patricia Ho, the lawyer acting for the teen.


A judge ruled in a youth court on Monday that the girl should be sent to a children's home for 20 days until January 19. On Wednesday, local media reported the girl was released from the children's home on bail.







The wall, known as the "Lennon Wall," was once covered with colorful Post-it notes and messages of support for the recent pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong. When the protests were cleared, the notes were removed as well.


Protestors started placing notes on the wall as a show of defiance after police used tear gas on demonstrators at the start of the protest, which lead to a two-month occupation of the main road outside the Central Government Office.


The wall was named after the late Beatles star John Lennon and contained messages of support for the protests and references to his song "Imagine."


'An innocent political prisoner'


Ho said the move was "premature and disproportionate."


"It wasn't an application by the Social Welfare Department as it usually would be," she said. "Police threw in a bunch of facts they obtained about the family in a very superficial manner."









The Goddess of Democracy (left image), erected by student protesters in 1989 in Tiananmen Square. The photo on the right shows a wooden statue of an umbrella man, created by an art graduate student who calls himself Milk. He told CNN he did not intend to link the piece with the Tiananmen symbol. The Goddess of Democracy (left image), erected by student protesters in 1989 in Tiananmen Square. The photo on the right shows a wooden statue of an umbrella man, created by an art graduate student who calls himself Milk. He told CNN he did not intend to link the piece with the Tiananmen symbol.



Since the umbrella was used to shield protesters from the tear gas and pepper spray deployed by police, it has become a ubiquitous sight in the protests, and given the movement its symbol. Here, the fabric of dozens of broken umbrellas have been stitched together to form a canopy. Since the umbrella was used to shield protesters from the tear gas and pepper spray deployed by police, it has become a ubiquitous sight in the protests, and given the movement its symbol. Here, the fabric of dozens of broken umbrellas have been stitched together to form a canopy.



Long an emblem of suffrage movements internationally, the yellow ribbons have been adopted by Hong Kong's protesters as a symbol of democratic aspiration. There are thousands tied on fences throughout Hong Kong.Long an emblem of suffrage movements internationally, the yellow ribbons have been adopted by Hong Kong's protesters as a symbol of democratic aspiration. There are thousands tied on fences throughout Hong Kong.



An image of an umbrella made up of yellow ribbons is laid out on the ground near the central government offices. The sign reads: "We can't live without civic nominations."An image of an umbrella made up of yellow ribbons is laid out on the ground near the central government offices. The sign reads: "We can't live without civic nominations."



The barrier separating the main road is lined with bright umbrellas. The barrier separating the main road is lined with bright umbrellas.



A student protester speaks into a microphone in front of a "democracy wall" filled with notes supporting the pro-democracy protest. The notes are protected from the rain with plastic wrap. A student protester speaks into a microphone in front of a "democracy wall" filled with notes supporting the pro-democracy protest. The notes are protected from the rain with plastic wrap.



Post-it messages filled with sketches and messages cover a wall next to a stairway in the Admiralty district in Hong Kong. Some of them are words of hope, and others denounce the Hong Kong's top official, the chief executive. Post-it messages filled with sketches and messages cover a wall next to a stairway in the Admiralty district in Hong Kong. Some of them are words of hope, and others denounce the Hong Kong's top official, the chief executive.



A couple walk past a banner of a man carrying a yellow umbrella, which has come to symbolize the protest. A couple walk past a banner of a man carrying a yellow umbrella, which has come to symbolize the protest.




The art of Hong Kong's protest



The art of Hong Kong\'s protestThe art of Hong Kong's protest



Meanwhile, the court is considering an application by Hong Kong police that she be removed from the care of her father who, according to Ho, is seriously hearing impaired and cannot understand the case.





Art bursts from Hong Kong protests

The move has angered activists; student activist group Scholarism have set up a petition protesting the court ruling and some protestors have started drawing on the road as a protest outside the children's home in Tuen Mun, where the teenager is being held.


Gary Tsang, who participated in Hong Kong's pro-democracy street occupations, told CNN the teen was "an innocent political prisoner" and the use of the law in this case was "obviously politically motivated."


"The government fears young people as they thinks young people have nothing to lose," he said.


Another protestor, Anson Chui, told CNN the police have lost their common sense and said there would be more similar arrests.


"Most (people)... know that we cannot really cause any damage on the wall by drawing with chalk," he said. "It is just an excuse used by the police to make us fear. Especially when the court said they are taking away the girl from her father."







The move comes after police also made an application for a care or protection order for a teenage boy who was arrested during the clearance of another protest site in Mong Kok earlier this month. The court file said the boy's parents failed to exercise proper guardianship over him.


The court dates for both teenagers will take place in January.


Continued resistance


A small protest camp outside the Legislative Council still remains and there is a small police presence on the site. Police officers are guarding Lennon Wall and remove all notes posted to it at the end of each day.


New Year's Eve countdown events at popular shopping districts such as Causeway Bay and Tsim Sha Tsui were canceled because of fears that protestors would attempt to hijack the events.


Since the protest sites were cleared, demonstrators have resorted to other forms of protest such as the so-called "shopping revolution," which involves protestors blocking the sidewalks and flooding shopping districts every night with yellow umbrellas.


Hong Kong Police have not responded to requests for comment.



1 comment:

  1. Teenagers in the USA are arrested for similar types of vandalism (graffiti especially) all the time, and given jail time for it too.

    ReplyDelete